| It's high in trans fat | 26 |
| It's found in tubs | 22 |
| It's believable that it's not butter | 44 |
| It's a butter alternative | 29 |
| It really isn't butter | 26 |
| It might be on a roll | 21 |
| It might be in a tub | 20 |
| It may not need clarification | 29 |
| It may come in pats | 19 |
| It fills some tubs | 18 |
| It could provide a pat on the buns | 34 |
| Ingredient in some cookies | 26 |
| Imperial, for example | 21 |
| I Can't Believe It's Not Butter | 39 |
| High-fat spread | 15 |
| Greasy spoon stuff | 18 |
| Greasing stuff | 14 |
| Golden spread | 13 |
| Frosting ingredient, often | 26 |
| Fridge stick | 12 |
| Fridge staple | 13 |
| Food product that melts | 23 |
| Food item sold in bars | 22 |
| Food item in quarter-pound sticks | 33 |
| Fat watcher's spread | 24 |
| Fat pat that spreads | 20 |
| Fat in a pat, maybe | 19 |
| Fat in a pat that spreads | 25 |
| Fake butter once legally required to be pink | 44 |
| Ersatz dairy stick | 18 |
| Edible emulsion | 15 |
| Early TV backdrop | 17 |
| Does it better butter? | 22 |
| Dieter's spread, maybe | 26 |
| Dieter's purchase | 21 |
| Dieter's choice | 19 |
| Dairy-free spread | 17 |
| Dairy-department item | 21 |
| Dairy tubful | 12 |
| Dairy spread | 12 |
| Dairy section purchase | 22 |
| Dairy section choice | 20 |
| Dairy case tubful | 17 |
| Dairy aisle tub | 15 |
| Corn product, at times | 22 |
| Cooking substitute | 18 |
| Cookery spread | 14 |
| Contents of a cool tub | 22 |
| Common butter substitute | 24 |
| Cold tub contents | 17 |
| Chromolithograph | 16 |
| Chromo | 6 |
| Cholesterol watcher's choice | 32 |
| Chiffon, for example | 20 |
| Cheaper topper | 14 |
| Cheap toast topper | 18 |
| Cake-pan coating | 16 |
| Buttery sub | 11 |
| Butterlike product | 18 |
| Butterine, in England | 21 |
| Butter's cousin | 19 |
| Breakfast-table spread | 22 |
| Breadspread? | 12 |
| Bread topping | 13 |
| Bread stick? | 12 |
| Bread cover | 11 |
| Bogus bar | 9 |
| Blue Bonnet spread | 18 |
| Bargain toast spread | 20 |
| Bar of yellow | 13 |
| Bar next to butter, maybe | 25 |
| Bar in the fridge, perhaps | 26 |
| Bar from a dairy case | 21 |
| Bakers' buy | 15 |
| Backdrop for a TV scene | 23 |
| Artificial bread spread | 23 |
| Airplane's strut | 20 |
| Airplane strut | 14 |
| A shortening, in more ways than one | 35 |
| A kind of spread | 16 |
| "I can't believe it's not butter" | 51 |
| ''I can't believe it's not butter'' | 59 |
| ___ strut, on a plane | 21 |
| ___ strut on a plane | 20 |
| ___ strut (landing gear shock absorber) | 39 |
| Corrida chant | 13 |
| Bullfight chant | 15 |
| Cheer at a soccer match | 23 |
| Chant in a ring | 15 |
| Spanish chant | 13 |
| Refrain from the song ''Hot Hot Hot'' | 53 |
| Enthusiastic shout | 18 |
| Words repeated in Buster Poindexter's "Hot Hot Hot" | 65 |
| South Africa 2010 chant | 23 |
| Soccer stadium chant | 20 |
| Ricardo's "Rah! Rah!" | 35 |
| Repeated Spanish phrase in "Hot Hot Hot" | 50 |
| Repeated phrase in "Hot Hot Hot" | 42 |
| Reinforced ring support? | 24 |
| Refrain from the song "Hot Hot Hot" | 45 |