| Show with six mysterious numbers | 32 |
| Series about stranded survivors | 31 |
| Required consolation, perhaps | 29 |
| Pixie-led | 9 |
| Misspent | 8 |
| Late for a party, maybe | 23 |
| Kind of soul | 12 |
| Irretrievable | 13 |
| Got beaten | 10 |
| Flubbed the game | 16 |
| Dropped, maybe | 14 |
| Asea | 4 |
| ABC series about crash survivors | 32 |
| ABC drama about plane crash survivors | 37 |
| "Love's Labour's ---" | 39 |
| "Love's Labour's ___" | 39 |
| "___ Horizon" | 23 |
| ''Love's Labour's ___'' | 47 |
| Word with Paradise or Horizon | 29 |
| Word in a Milton title | 22 |
| Won the battle of the bulge | 27 |
| Went into the tank | 18 |
| Wasted, as a chance | 19 |
| Was worsted | 11 |
| Was second-best | 15 |
| Was checkmated | 14 |
| Was bested | 10 |
| Was beaten | 10 |
| Unretrievable | 13 |
| Unable to understand | 20 |
| Type of cause or motion | 23 |
| TV show that debuted on 9/22/04 (middle of the cry) | 51 |
| TV show set on a Pacific island | 31 |
| TV show inspired by the video game "Myst" | 51 |
| TV show featuring "The Others" | 40 |
| TV series filmed on Oahu | 24 |
| Took the count | 14 |
| The story of the aftermath of Oceanic Flight 815 | 48 |
| The ____ World | 14 |
| The ____ Boys of "Peter Pan" | 38 |
| Sullivan's "The ___ Chord" | 40 |
| Show with mysterious hatches | 28 |
| Show featuring "Hurley" Reyes | 39 |
| Series with multiple timelines | 30 |
| Series that aired its final episode in May 2010 | 47 |
| Series set on a mysterious island | 33 |
| Series about survivors with secrets | 35 |
| Ransom's "Lady ___" | 33 |
| Quite befuddled | 15 |
| Post–W.W. I generation | 29 |
| Picked the short straw | 22 |
| Out the window | 14 |
| Oceanic Flight 815 series | 25 |
| Not to be found | 15 |
| Not grasping the material, say | 30 |
| Not found | 9 |
| Not following | 13 |
| Not comprehending at all | 24 |
| No longer visible | 17 |
| Neil Simon's "___ in Yonkers" | 43 |
| Needing directions, say | 23 |
| More than just hard to find | 27 |
| Misguided Coldplay song? | 24 |
| Misguided Avenged Sevenfold song? | 33 |
| Mis-placed | 10 |
| Milton's "Paradise ___" | 37 |
| Matthew Fox series | 18 |
| Locationally challenged? | 24 |
| Like Shangri-La's horizon | 29 |
| Like Miss Procter's chord | 29 |
| Like Lucy Locket's pocket | 29 |
| Like Hemingway's generation | 31 |
| Let slip by | 11 |
| Lacking assurance | 17 |
| Lacking a clue | 14 |
| Kipling's "The ___ Legion" | 40 |
| J.J. Abrams show filmed mostly in Hawaii | 40 |
| J.J. Abrams series | 18 |
| J. J. Abrams TV drama | 21 |
| J. Geils: "Must of got ___" | 37 |
| It tells the tale of the survivors of Oceanic Flight 815 | 56 |
| Island series | 13 |
| Island drama | 12 |
| In unfamiliar territory, maybe | 30 |
| In need of a map, maybe | 23 |
| Hopeless, as a cause | 20 |
| Hit ABC TV show featuring "The Others" | 48 |
| Hit ABC series set on an island | 31 |
| Hit ABC series | 14 |
| Hit ABC drama about plane crash survivors | 41 |
| Hilton's horizon | 20 |
| High-rated ABC series | 21 |
| Got upset | 9 |
| Going in circles, maybe | 23 |
| Going around in circles, maybe | 30 |
| Found's opposite | 20 |
| Found partner | 13 |
| Forfeit or forfeited | 20 |
| Failed to keep | 14 |
| Drama that began with a plane crash | 35 |