| Good Charlotte's singer Madden | 34 |
| Good Charlotte singer Madden | 28 |
| Follower of Hosea | 17 |
| Early host of "Mystery Science Theater 3000" | 54 |
| Director Schumacher | 19 |
| Bronx-born piano man | 20 |
| Billy with a piano | 18 |
| Billy who sang "We Didn't Start the Fire" | 55 |
| Billy the "Piano Man" | 31 |
| Billy in the Songwriters Hall of Fame | 37 |
| Billy in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame | 39 |
| Billy a.k.a. the Piano Man | 26 |
| Author _____ Chandler Harris | 28 |
| Actor Grey | 10 |
| "Uptown Girl" singer | 30 |
| "River of Dreams" singer Billy | 40 |
| "Pressure" singer Billy | 33 |
| "Piano Man" performer Billy | 37 |
| "Only the Good Die Young" Billy | 41 |
| "My Life" singer, 1978 | 32 |
| "Just the Way You Are" songwriter | 43 |
| "It's Still Rock and Roll to Me" singer Billy | 59 |
| "Community" star McHale | 33 |
| "52nd Street" performer Billy | 39 |
| 'Piano Man' singer Billy | 32 |
| ''Piano Man'' artist | 36 |
| 60's-70's TV sleuth | 27 |
| '70s TV sleuth | 18 |
| Super Bowl III MVP | 18 |
| Renowned ex-quarterback | 23 |
| 1965 AFL Rookie of the Year | 27 |
| Winning Super Bowl III quarterback | 34 |
| Quarterback who guaranteed a win in Super Bowl III | 50 |
| Bear Bryant called him "the greatest athlete I ever coached" | 70 |
| "Love Ranch" star | 27 |
| "My Cousin Vinny" star | 32 |
| "Home Alone" actor | 28 |
| "GoodFellas" Oscar winner | 35 |
| "Casino" co-star | 26 |
| "Home Alone" costar | 29 |
| Oscar winner who appeared in a Snickers ad | 42 |
| "Jimmy Hollywood" star | 32 |
| "I mean, funny like I'm a clown?" speaker | 55 |
| Average guys | 12 |
| Trader ___ | 10 |
| Regular guys | 12 |
| Stereotypical diner name | 24 |
| Generic comic strip diner | 25 |
| DiMaggio and Louis | 18 |
| "Regular" guys | 24 |
| Torre and Girardi | 17 |
| Stereotypical sandwich board diner | 34 |
| Smokey ___ (Broadway hit locale) | 32 |
| Sloppy guys? | 12 |
| Rockers Strummer and Cocker | 27 |
| Popular GIs | 11 |
| Ordinary guys | 13 |
| Lieberman and Louis | 19 |
| Frank Zappa rock opera "___ Garage" | 45 |
| College and Friday | 18 |
| College and Blow | 16 |
| Blow and Cool | 13 |
| Average fellows | 15 |
| Average fellas | 14 |
| "Smokey ___ Cafe" | 27 |
| "Eat at ___" (classic sign) | 37 |
| "Eat at ___" | 22 |
| "Eat at _____" | 24 |
| He could be anybody | 19 |
| Ordinary fellow | 15 |
| Reality show victim | 19 |
| Random guy | 10 |
| Middle America symbol of 2008 politics | 38 |
| Metaphor for a middle-class American | 36 |
| Campaign '08 personality | 28 |
| 2008 campaign personality | 25 |
| "Friends" friend | 26 |
| Baby kangaroo | 13 |
| Young kangaroo | 14 |
| Kangaroo kid | 12 |
| Bishop of old TV | 16 |
| Bishop | 6 |
| "Friends" spinoff | 27 |
| Roo, for one | 12 |
| Roo, for instance | 17 |
| Milne's Roo, e.g. | 21 |
| Comic Bishop | 12 |
| Bishop of the Rat Pack | 22 |
| Baby bouncer? | 13 |
| Youngster in a pouch | 20 |
| Russo with the '90s catchphrase "Whoa!" | 53 |
| Roo, at birth | 13 |
| Post-"Friends" flop | 29 |
| Pooh's pal Roo, e.g. | 24 |
| O'Hara Pal | 14 |
| Nickname for a namesake of Mary's husband | 45 |
| Newfoundland's Smallwood | 28 |
| New sitcom of 2004 | 18 |
| Legendary Newfoundlander | 24 |
| Koala kid | 9 |