| Fair alternative | 16 |
| Court error | 11 |
| Clipping or tripping | 20 |
| Clipping on a gridiron, e.g. | 28 |
| Ball hit out of bounds | 22 |
| Awful-smelling | 14 |
| ___ tip | 7 |
| ___ play | 8 |
| __ tip | 6 |
| Disagreeable disposition | 24 |
| Tendency to anger easily | 24 |
| Strikeout averter, perhaps | 26 |
| One might be caught for an out | 30 |
| Barely struck strike | 20 |
| Barely batted ball | 18 |
| Ball that may hit an umpire | 27 |
| Disgusting advice? | 18 |
| Barely batted balls | 19 |
| Peak that reeks? | 16 |
| Major mess | 10 |
| Major messes | 12 |
| Picnic spoiler | 14 |
| Cold, wind and sleet, e.g. | 26 |
| Came across | 11 |
| Stumbled upon | 13 |
| Stumbled on to | 14 |
| No longer lost | 14 |
| New ___ Glory | 13 |
| Lost partner? | 13 |
| Lost partner | 12 |
| Lost no more | 12 |
| Half of a store department | 26 |
| Add vertical line 1 (word 1) and vertical line 15 (word 3) and enter the answer to the resulting clue on this line | 114 |
| Uses as a basis | 15 |
| Ponce de León's quest | 28 |
| An impossible dream | 19 |
| WARNING: Effects on children unknown | 36 |
| Spa that never was | 18 |
| Ponce de Leon pursuit | 21 |
| Object of a Ponce de León search | 35 |
| Mythical spring of restoration sought by Ponce de León | 57 |
| Legendary spring that creates spring chickens? | 46 |
| Legendary spring | 16 |
| Elusive quest of explorers | 26 |
| De Leon's quest | 19 |
| Ageless quest | 13 |
| "Impossible" discovery | 32 |
| Calligraphy tool | 16 |
| Calligraphy aid | 15 |
| Writer with a well | 18 |
| Writer with a reservoir | 23 |
| Quaint graduation gift | 22 |
| Prison for soda jerks? | 22 |
| It's filled from a well | 27 |
| Implement with ink | 18 |
| Ballpoint forerunner | 20 |
| Atonement from a soda jerk? | 27 |
| Wee hour | 8 |
| Afternoon hour | 14 |
| Quartet | 7 |
| Tea time | 8 |
| Small square | 12 |
| Polo team | 9 |
| Quartet count | 13 |
| Number of Gospels | 17 |
| Number of apocalyptic horsemen | 30 |
| Gettysburg Address starter | 26 |
| They may be on the floor | 24 |
| Tea time, perhaps | 17 |
| Quad number | 11 |
| Number in a quartet | 19 |
| Lou Gehrig's number | 23 |
| Lou Gehrig, on the diamond | 26 |
| Barbershop group | 16 |
| Afternoon hour for tea | 22 |
| ___ Corners (Western intersection) | 34 |
| ___ Corners (Western intersection of note) | 42 |
| Word with square or star | 24 |
| Word with score or square | 25 |
| What leap years are divisible by | 32 |
| Typical number of theme answers in a crossword | 46 |
| Typical barbershop complement | 29 |
| Two squared | 11 |
| Two by two? | 11 |
| Time that little Susie is woken in the 1957 hit "Wake Up Little Susie" | 80 |
| The last ball | 13 |
| The first positive non-Fibonacci number | 39 |
| The Fantastic ___ (superhero group) | 35 |
| Tetrad | 6 |
| Teatime, maybe | 14 |
| Teatime | 7 |
| Tea time, traditionally | 23 |
| Tea hour | 8 |
| Suit count | 10 |
| Square of the only even prime | 29 |
| Quaternary | 10 |
| Quartet's makeup | 20 |
| Quartet quorum | 14 |
| Quartet number | 14 |
| Quantity in hand, sartorially | 29 |