| Peyton's successor as Super Bowl MVP | 40 |
| Peyton's quarterback brother | 32 |
| Peyton's QB brother | 23 |
| Peyton's kid brother | 24 |
| Peyton's gridiron brother | 29 |
| Peyton's brother on the gridiron | 36 |
| Peyton's brother in the NFL | 31 |
| Peyton Manning's bro | 24 |
| Person singing "Boola Boola" perhaps | 46 |
| Peabody Museum patron, perhaps | 30 |
| Passing Manning | 15 |
| One wearing a "Y" shirt, perhaps | 42 |
| One sporting a blue cap with a white Y | 38 |
| One of the Whitneys | 19 |
| One of the NFL Mannings | 23 |
| One of the Manning quarterbacks | 31 |
| One of the Manning NFLers | 25 |
| One of the gridiron Mannings | 28 |
| One of certain Bulldogs | 23 |
| One of Archie's three sons | 30 |
| One "coming" in a Three Dog Night hit | 47 |
| Old Testament priest who taught Samuel | 38 |
| Old Testament high priest | 25 |
| Obama: Crimsonite :: Clinton : ___ | 34 |
| Oater actor Wallach | 19 |
| O. T. teacher | 13 |
| Nutmeg State collegian | 22 |
| Noted gin-maker | 15 |
| Nordic nickname for Helena | 26 |
| Noah Webster, while living in Connecticut Hall | 46 |
| Noah Webster, while in college | 30 |
| NFLer Manning | 13 |
| NFL Overall #1 Draft pick between Carson and Alex | 49 |
| NFL notable Manning | 19 |
| NFL first name | 14 |
| New Havenite | 12 |
| New Haven reuner | 16 |
| New Haven nickname | 18 |
| New Haven collegiate | 20 |
| New Haven collegian hidden in this puzzle's longest entries | 63 |
| New Haven coed | 14 |
| New Haven Bulldog | 17 |
| New Haven alum, Whitney | 23 |
| Nathan Hale, circa 1772 | 23 |
| Name that becomes another name when an F is added to the front and an X to the end | 82 |
| Name in gin articles | 20 |
| Musician/record producer Bobby | 30 |
| Mr. Lilly | 9 |
| Michigan's ___ Broad College of Business | 44 |
| Meryl Streep, circa 1974 | 24 |
| Member of the Whiffenpoofs, e.g. | 32 |
| Member of the a capella group Spizzwinks(?) | 43 |
| Marrero of the St. Louis Cardinals | 34 |
| Marrero of the Mets | 19 |
| Mark and Tim's cross-town rival QB | 38 |
| Manning with two Super Bowl MVPs | 32 |
| Manning with two Super Bowl championships | 41 |
| Manning with a ring | 19 |
| Manning whose team missed the playoffs in 2010 | 46 |
| Manning who'd better throw fewer interceptions this year, damn it | 69 |
| Manning who has won multiple Super Bowl M.V.P. awards | 53 |
| Manning the quarterback | 23 |
| Manning the Giant | 17 |
| Manning or Whitney | 18 |
| Lilly, the drug maker | 21 |
| Lilly or Witney | 15 |
| Lilly or Manning | 16 |
| Lilly of Lilly Pharmaceutical | 29 |
| Lilly of drugs | 14 |
| Lilly native to Maryland | 24 |
| Letter Y sporter | 16 |
| Letter "Y" wearer | 27 |
| Left fielder Marrero | 20 |
| Lawyer on TV's "Civil Wars" | 41 |
| Lawyer in both "Civil Wars" and "L.A. Law" | 62 |
| Laura Nyro album "___ and the Thirteenth Confession" | 62 |
| Late actor Wallach | 18 |
| Larry Kelly was one | 19 |
| Judge-priest in Samuel | 22 |
| Judge served by Samuel | 22 |
| Judge in the Old Testament | 26 |
| Judge in 1 Samuel | 17 |
| John Kerry or George Bush, once | 31 |
| Ivy man | 7 |
| Ivy Leaguer student | 19 |
| Ivy League bulldog | 18 |
| Inventor's name | 19 |
| Inventor–clock-maker Terry | 33 |
| Inventor Witney | 15 |
| Inventor Whitney, for one | 25 |
| Inventor Wallach | 16 |
| Installation artist Sudbrack | 28 |
| Ingenious Whitney | 17 |
| Indiana's Colonel ___ Lilly Civil War Museum | 48 |
| Horror filmmaker Roth | 21 |
| Horologist Terry | 16 |
| Hophni's father | 19 |
| Hirer of the stunt man in "The Stunt Man" | 51 |
| High, to a Hebrew | 17 |
| High, in Hebrew | 15 |