| Hall of Famer Rod | 17 |
| Hall of Famer Robin of the Milwaukee Brewers | 44 |
| Hall of Famer Ripken | 20 |
| Hall of Famer Reese | 19 |
| Hall of Famer Ralph | 19 |
| Hall of Famer on the dairy farm baseball team? | 46 |
| Hall of Famer Nolan | 19 |
| Hall of Famer nicknamed "Rapid Robert" | 48 |
| Hall of Famer nicknamed "Knucksie" | 44 |
| Hall of Famer Musial | 20 |
| Hall of Famer Monte | 19 |
| Hall of Famer Mickey | 20 |
| Hall of Famer Mel | 17 |
| Hall of Famer Lynn of the Steelers | 34 |
| Hall of Famer Lefty | 19 |
| Hall of Famer Lajoie | 20 |
| Hall of Famer Johnny | 20 |
| Hall of Famer Ford who pitched for the Yankees | 46 |
| Hall of Famer Durocher | 22 |
| Hall of Famer Carew | 19 |
| Hall of Famer Brock | 19 |
| Hall of Famer Brimsek was one | 29 |
| Hall of Famer born in Panama | 28 |
| Hall of Famer Berra | 19 |
| Hall of Famer Aparicio | 22 |
| Hall of Famer | 13 |
| Hall of fame? | 13 |
| Hall of Fame's Cap | 22 |
| Hall of Fame wannabe | 20 |
| Hall of Fame vocalist Redding | 29 |
| Hall of Fame Vikings lineman Carl | 33 |
| Hall of Fame units | 18 |
| Hall of Fame umpire Conlan | 26 |
| Hall of Fame umpire Chylak | 26 |
| Hall of Fame umpire Barlick and others | 38 |
| Hall of Fame Tiger Al | 21 |
| Hall of Fame third baseman George | 33 |
| Hall of Fame surgeon | 20 |
| Hall of Fame subject of "The Last Boy" | 48 |
| Hall of Fame strikeout king | 27 |
| Hall of Fame stat | 17 |
| Hall of Fame sportscaster Curt | 30 |
| Hall of Fame southpaw Warren | 28 |
| Hall of Fame slugger Ralph | 26 |
| Hall of Fame slugger Johnny | 27 |
| Hall of Fame skier Nancy | 24 |
| Hall of fame skier Lucille | 26 |
| Hall of fame skier Laurie | 25 |
| Hall of fame skier Kerrin | 25 |
| Hall of fame skier Kathy | 24 |
| Hall of fame skier Karen | 24 |
| Hall of Fame sight | 18 |
| Hall of Fame shortstop Vaughan | 30 |
| Hall of Fame shortstop Smith | 28 |
| Hall of Fame shortstop Ozzie | 28 |
| Hall of Fame shortstop known as "The Scooter" | 55 |
| Hall of Fame shortstop Joe | 26 |
| Hall of Fame shortstop Aparicio | 31 |
| Hall of Fame shortstop | 22 |
| Hall of Fame second baseman Sandberg | 36 |
| Hall of Fame second baseman Bobby | 33 |
| Hall of Fame safety Ronnie | 26 |
| Hall of Fame running back Campbell | 34 |
| Hall of Fame receiver | 21 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback Y.A. | 29 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback Troy | 29 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback Tarkenton | 34 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback Luckman | 32 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback Johnny | 31 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback John | 29 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback Graham | 31 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback Dawson | 31 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback Baugh | 30 |
| Hall of Fame quarterback | 24 |
| Hall of Fame QB turned color commentator Dan | 44 |
| Hall of Fame QB Graham | 22 |
| Hall of Fame QB Dawson | 22 |
| Hall of Fame QB Dan | 19 |
| Hall of Fame QB Bob | 19 |
| Hall of Fame pro wrestler known for wearing a kilt | 50 |
| Hall of Fame pop group The Four __, and last of this puzzle theme's five anagrams | 85 |
| Hall of Fame pool player __ Mataya Laurance | 43 |
| Hall of Fame placekicker Groza | 30 |
| Hall of Fame pitchers Bunning and Palmer | 40 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher-citrus grower? | 35 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher ___ Wynn | 29 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Wilhelm | 28 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Warren | 27 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Waite __ | 29 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Spahn | 26 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher since '97 | 34 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Seaver's nickname | 42 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Ryan | 25 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Red | 24 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Perry | 26 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Lyons | 26 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher known as "Bullet Bob" | 52 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Eckersley | 30 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Coveleski | 30 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Blyleven | 29 |