| Like a siren | 12 |
| Like a sinner | 13 |
| Like a single-performer show | 28 |
| Like a single sock | 18 |
| Like a single shoe | 18 |
| Like a singer/songwriter | 24 |
| Like a simple task | 18 |
| Like a Simonized car | 20 |
| Like a Simon couple | 19 |
| Like a silent night | 19 |
| Like a sighting of an ivory-billed woodpecker | 45 |
| Like a sieve | 12 |
| Like a sideways glance | 22 |
| Like a sidewalk café | 23 |
| Like a sidebar | 14 |
| Like a Siberian Husky's ears | 32 |
| Like a shyster, often | 21 |
| Like a shutout | 14 |
| Like a shrinking violet | 23 |
| Like a shrike, e.g. | 19 |
| Like a shrike | 13 |
| Like a showstopper | 18 |
| Like a shower mat, ideally | 26 |
| Like a shower door, sometimes | 29 |
| Like a show that has the audience on its feet? (abbr.) | 54 |
| Like a show horse? | 18 |
| Like a shot | 11 |
| Like a short play | 17 |
| Like a short golf round | 23 |
| Like a short film | 17 |
| Like a shoppe | 13 |
| Like a shooting star | 20 |
| Like a shoe | 11 |
| Like a shitty boss? | 19 |
| Like a shirker | 14 |
| Like a ship without ___ | 23 |
| Like a ship trapped in the Arctic Ocean | 39 |
| Like a ship on the ocean floor | 30 |
| Like a ship at the Tate | 23 |
| Like a ship at sea, to a hippie? | 32 |
| Like a shepherd's staff | 27 |
| Like a shepherd's crook | 27 |
| Like a shepherd's charges | 29 |
| Like a Shelley tribute | 22 |
| Like a sheet of stamps | 22 |
| Like a sheer nightie | 20 |
| Like a sheer negligee | 21 |
| Like a sheepdog | 15 |
| Like a sheep | 12 |
| Like a shaving | 14 |
| Like a sharpshooter, e.g. | 25 |
| Like a sharpshooter's aim | 29 |
| Like a Shakespearean "Ta-da!" | 39 |
| Like a shake roof | 17 |
| Like a shaggy dog | 17 |
| Like a shady lane | 17 |
| Like a sgt. or cpl. | 19 |
| Like a sexist joke, briefly | 27 |
| Like a sexist joke | 18 |
| Like a sewer | 12 |
| Like a seventh of the world's people | 40 |
| Like a seven-footer | 19 |
| Like a sesame seed? | 19 |
| Like a sesame bagel | 19 |
| Like a serving of eels, perhaps | 31 |
| Like a service station floor | 28 |
| Like a serious sin | 18 |
| Like a serious issue | 20 |
| Like a series finale? | 21 |
| Like a serial story | 19 |
| Like a serial | 13 |
| Like a serape | 13 |
| Like a sequoia | 14 |
| Like a Seoul man | 16 |
| Like a sentry, presumably | 25 |
| Like a sentry | 13 |
| Like a self-cleaning oven, say | 30 |
| Like a seine | 12 |
| Like a secure ship | 18 |
| Like a secret that's no longer secret | 41 |
| Like a secret missive | 21 |
| Like a secret cable | 19 |
| Like a second-rate actor | 24 |
| Like a searchlight | 18 |
| Like a seaman's humor, stereotypically | 42 |
| Like a seaman's humor | 25 |
| Like a Seabee's assignment | 30 |
| Like a sea? | 11 |
| Like a sea lion | 15 |
| Like a scrubbed space mission | 29 |
| Like a scrubbed mirror | 22 |
| Like a screened porch | 21 |
| Like a Scrabble board in play | 29 |
| Like a Scottish young 'un | 29 |
| Like a score of 10 out of 10 | 28 |
| Like a score of 10 of a possible 10 | 35 |
| Like a score of 10 for 10 | 25 |
| Like a schoolyard bully | 23 |
| Like a schoolmarm | 17 |
| Like a school tablet | 20 |