| Puzzle video game with three heroes | 35 |
| Puzzle with a start and a finish | 32 |
| Puzzle with an "Enter" instruction | 44 |
| Puzzle with its pluses and minuses? | 35 |
| Puzzle's theme (said by a young cyclist!) | 45 |
| Puzzle's theme was his campaign song | 40 |
| Puzzle-theme mystery writer: 1809-1849 | 38 |
| Puzzlemaker Caleb Madison, collegially | 38 |
| Puzzler's favorite Anglo-Saxon | 34 |
| Puzzler's favorite Italian family | 37 |
| Puzzler's popular piano piece | 33 |
| Puzzles involving quotes, usually | 33 |
| Puzzles on kid-friendly place mats | 34 |
| Puzzling prefix for "gram" | 36 |
| Pygmalion playwright's monogram | 38 |
| Pyle's "___ of Iron" | 34 |
| Pyncheon's pride, punny style | 33 |
| Pyramid topper on the back of a $1 bill | 39 |
| Pyramids of Egypt, Colossus at Rhodes... | 40 |
| Pythias' substitute as hostage | 34 |
| Python in "The Jungle Book" | 37 |