Proper sort ... or a cry upon solving each of this puzzle's theme answers?

Question:

Answer:

GOODYTWOSHOES

Length:

Similar Crossword Questions:

"Gosh!" (or, based on the starts of starred answers, one who is expert at solving this puzzle's theme?)
Grate, with "get," or what this puzzle's theme answers get
"Home work" letters that appear at both ends of this puzzle's theme answers
Postseason gridiron game, and a hint to the puzzle theme found in starred answers
Second letters of this puzzle's five theme answers (seen in order)
___ to school . . . or a hint to the puzzle theme suggested by the ends of five answers
Term for each of the 15 asterisked theme answers in this puzzle
What presidential term limits mercifully ensure, and each of this puzzle's theme answers "receives"
New element whose name will be ratified in January, 2010, and whose symbol appears in the middle of this puzzle's theme answers
Supplements added to each of this puzzle's theme answers
Where one might see the sounds embedded in this puzzle's theme answers
"Something you would cheat on if you knew you wouldn't get caught." "___" (also, the source of this puzzle's theme answers)
What this puzzle's theme answers contain (if you look closely enough)
Feature of this puzzle's theme answers?
Compound found in perfume and this puzzle's theme answers
Word before the first word in this puzzle's theme answers
Records "broken" in this puzzle's nine theme answers
Struck out, as one letter in each of this puzzle's theme answers
HBO's "Inside the __" (and hidden theme in this puzzle's four longest answers)
Like the theme answers in this puzzle?
Out of whack, or what's featured in each of this puzzle's theme answers
Plummet ... or what this puzzle's theme answers do?
Number of times this puzzle's theme word appears diagonally in the grid (to complete the puzzle, shade those words plus the Down answers that begin where they meet)
"The wart stops here" product, and a hint to the theme found in eight puzzle answers
Upright, and what's been removed to form this puzzle's theme answers