Proper sort ... or a cry upon solving each of this puzzle's theme answers?

Question:

Answer:

GOODYTWOSHOES

Length:

Similar Crossword Questions:

"Gosh!" (or, based on the starts of starred answers, one who is expert at solving this puzzle's theme?)
Struck out, as one letter in each of this puzzle's theme answers
Shoe additions, and what this puzzle's theme answers contain
Big fight, and clue to this puzzle's theme that begins the four longest answers
What the self-contradictory words found in this puzzle's theme answers are examples of
Theme of this puzzle hidden in the seven other longest across answers
Alternative words used as alternatives for each other in this puzzle's theme answers
Comic that comes to an end on October 3rd, and whose catchphrase ends this puzzle's theme answers
Some film credits, and the idea behind the eight theme answers in this puzzle
Write in any of this puzzle's eight theme answers?
ConfuseÂ—or what to do to four common phrases to form this puzzle's theme answers
Letters for the names "buried" in this puzzle's theme answers
What one must have to solve this puzzle's theme answers
Environmental slogan, or a hint to this puzzle's theme answers
Equipment for each of this puzzle's theme answers
What one gets by multiplying the numbers in this puzzle's theme answers
Weather Channel feature (it's the puzzle theme found in a quintet of answers)
"Dog the Bounty Hunter" network, and a hint to the theme in this puzzle's four longest answers
Shade from the sun that's inserted in this puzzle's theme answers
Grate, with "get," or what this puzzle's theme answers get
"Home work" letters that appear at both ends of this puzzle's theme answers
Postseason gridiron game, and a hint to the puzzle theme found in starred answers
Reservoir, and hint to puzzle theme found in seven long answers
Second letters of this puzzle's five theme answers (seen in order)
This puzzle's theme found in the answers to five asterisked clues